Definitely looks as though I'll be running it a hybrid. Perhaps with judging for all categories and a popular vote for general ones like 'Best Overall Fic' in which all nominees are included.

I'm a whore for judging, so like PM me or something if that happens.

That would be awesome! I'm currently in the nominations stage of the White Knight Awards (Xander - popular vote) and am committed to running the Salt & Burn Awards (Supernatural - judged) in July/August so it will probably be August or maybe even into September before this goes ahead. Thank you so much for the offer!